Alegroth's art Reviews on Newgrounds

[Takkar Level up]

Second try to comment on this masterpiece! My first comment disappeared due to some server error or something?

I think this piece is amazing, the poses, colering, scene setup and the transition from level 1 to 99 is amazing. You can really recognize the charecter and even though I don't know the game from which this is from that well I got the reference. Additionally you master a skill I wish I had and that's when to STOP drawing detail to get more depth of view in the image. Perfect examples of this is the owl and the background. The fur is amazingly drawn as well and so is the armor design.

Two minor things though! First, the background behind the two images (the rock there) is low res which is a shame due to the quality of the rest. Second, the coat on the Level 99 charecter sort of melds with the background a bt much so it's hard to see what it is. I only saw it properly when I checked your wips. However, I'm not sure I am even worthy of commenting on your work, jawdroppingly good! I am looking forward to browsing your collection.

Cheers,
Dr. Emil Alégroth

Neutronboar responds:

Thank you,Dr. Emil , for taking time to write such an extensive, very positive and insightful review. I have a suspicion why your first attempt was lost. That probably was my fault. Thank you twice then.

[Kirby LVL 99]

Haha, some great nightmare fuel right there :) I like the image and depiction of the scene with well chosen and executed cloathing from the charecters he has devoured ;) The only thing I'D comment on is that the inside of the mouth should have been in more shadow to give more depth. Otherwise a really cool piece :)

OscArt responds:

I agree, the inside of the mouth should be darker. I think I'll fix that after Jazza posts his video.

[Dark Side K2SO | Rogue One | Level Cap COTM]

Great execution and fun idea. Good level of detail on the charecter contra the background, adding to the sense of depth in the image. Colors and shading is also well executed and sets a nice mood. Finally the pose is nice because he looks almost sad because of what he has had to do. Top notch piece :)

MartsArt responds:

Thank you so much for this review :D

[February]

Really dark but interesting image. Difficult to read exactly what has happened, why this woman is in the water, apparently bound. Had a nice little moment of going through some scenarios for the image, which I guess is the sign of a good painting :) In terms of execution I like that this started as a traditional piece, especially with watercolor as a medium! Really cool. Just which her right arm had been a bit thinner and that her right breast a bit rounder to match the left one better? Anyhow, great work, had been 5/5 if it hadn't been for the little twerks I mentioned.

Elionette responds:

Hi there! I appreciate your review and I'm so pleased it made you think! As for your critique, most breasts don't match, and one of her arms is further behind her to make it seem as if she's moving. I'm sorry it didn't read, so thank you for your critique, I will work on those things in future pieces! I just wished to clarify in case it makes you see the image in a new way.

[(Reminiscing) Portrait Study No.5]

The lighting in this image is amazing. Especially on the right side of her face. The subtle transitions into the blue is soo smoth I had to really look to see it. My brain was like: "yeah, this looks like a person, nothing to see here". But that's what makes this soooo good! I had to think to realize that it's an image almost :) Really well done, the pose and that stare into nothingness (saw in another comment that that was what you were going for) is just great. Amazing.

rainwalker007 responds:

Thank you so much for all the kind words. It has been a nice practice. Using 2 light sources for a portrait is a joy. Glad you liked it :)

['Empress of Tides']

My jaw dropped a little bit when I brought up the image. The charecter looks really cool and really answers the question what happened after the movies. Although, and on the other hand, now I want to see what actually happened as Ariel clearly has gone through some strife. Not to mention what happened to Blunder to make him that badass ;) The only thing that I would liked to have changed in the skull in her hand. It's size implies that it's a child skull almost, which makes the image VERY dark, and its coloring seems a bit to white for the environment. Regardless, I'm nitpicking. This piece is amazing! Well done.

Djoresh responds:

Haha, thanks. I notice it now as well. Her face used to be a bit smaller, about the same size as the skull, but it didn't feel right, I forgot to enlarge the skull along with her face, oops... It does give it a unintended darker edge. The skull is indeed to white. I should have made it more blue-like because it's in the water surrounded by blue light. Thank you for the pointers, I try to keep them in mind for future pieces

[Necropolitan Ice-Scream]

Really cool, love how the icecream still looks edible and taste whilts still being super nasty monsterous... things!

Aron-Ato responds:

Thanks xD

[The Little Mermaid]

Really nice image, very gloomy. The underwater effect is really well done, perspective and proportions are also really well put together. The background also seems massive even though there isn't that much in it really. Just well choosen colors. Great work.

ArtbyGalen responds:

Thank you so much! I really appreciate that!

[If Luigi Could Level Up - Jazza COTM May 2017 'LEVEL CAP']

Low the artstyle, very close to the games, yet with a clear personal flare. Fits well with the COTM and I like the cartoon :) Not quite sure what the last frame means but otherwise really cool and I keep finding details, like Marios fot being outside the border in the last frame. Cool : Hade rater 5/5 if you'd used another font for the speachbubbles, a bit difficult to read.

JerBer7 responds:

Thank you very much for both the praise and the criticisms! When going creating the font, I tried to make it chicken-scrathy so that it would seem urgent and seem like they were screaming. I probably could have found a font to do what I wanted that would have looked better, but I was under the impression initially that it was due at midnight last night, so I was hurrying to finish it.

Again, I'm glad that you liked it so much! Thank you for the input!

[Lvl 99 Roberto]

Lol! This was funny. The idea and the execution of the pice is great. Love the transition from a fidgetspinner to roberto to level 99 roberto. Very inovative and the final design is cool, mixing old japanese armour with the futurama style. Great work.

Best regards,
Dr. Emil Alégroth

NatalyJa responds:

Thank you so much for the comment, you made my day.